When I first took the GRE (Graduate Record Examination—a standardized test used before a student can enter graduate school) in 1989, I scored off the chart. Seriously, I was in top 2% of the entire country in GRE test scores. When I retook the test 4 years ago, my scores were less impressive. Does this mean that at forty, I was less prepared for grad school than when I was 25? Does it mean that I was less smart? What exactly do my two GRE scores mean? ABSOLUTELY NOTHING! Well—at least nothing important, that is.
My GRE score drop means that the first time I took the exam, I was a recent college graduate and still spoke the language of academia. I was no less intelligent in my forties and I was actually better prepared for grad school, as age had taught me to appreciate education more. In case you haven’t figure out yet where this is going—it is time for Kendra’s annual “Why Standardized Tests are a Waste of Time and Money” column.
What sparked this spate of vitriol? My fifth grader brought a note home inviting parents to school for a discussion on the importance of the ITBS and instruction on how to make sure students are adequately prepared to take the exam. The letter even offered the bribe of pizza for parents who come. So let me get this straight: I am expected to take a day off from work to learn how to prepare my child for an exam that every single knowledgeable person in the entire universe says is worthless (and my knowledgeable I mean EDUCATORS—not POLITICIANS)?
To be clear: I am not blaming Patrick’s school for this, but the entire culture in education that has decided that standardized test scores are not only the BEST, but the ONLY way to evaluate the effectiveness of a school. This attitude comes from the top. Starting with the hated “No Child Left Behind” policy, implemented by President Bush and continued by President Obama, standardized tests have become THE way to evaluate and then punish schools for their performance. There are few rewards in this system. As a matter of fact, under the current policy a school that does really super duper well one year can be punished in subsequent years if their scores slip. So—schools want to do a little bit better each year on the test—but not so much better that they can’t replicate or even best the results in the following years. Insanity.
I have many friends that teach in Iowa’s public schools that are being told openly that if it “isn’t on the test, don’t teach it.” My friends know this is wrong and I daresay the administrators that issue edicts such as these know it is wrong—but they have no choice, but to do as told. School funding, accreditation, and even teachers’ jobs depend on how well students do on standardized tests.
As a college instructor, I want my students to be able to THINK, not fill in little circles with a number two pencil. I want them to be able to decipher abstract problems and use their creativity to find unique solutions. I’m thinking employers value these skills as well. None of these skills are tested on the ITEDs.
I realize that “accountability” is the big buzzword in education these days, but standardized tests should never be the ONLY way to judge a school’s effectiveness as they pretty much are now. I know Paddy’s teachers are doing a great job—whether he scores 95% on his Basic Skills test or if he decides to play connect-the-dots and scores 15%. Kids are unpredictable in many different ways and to judge their school’s effectiveness solely on a standardized test is ridiculous. It’s about time the Department of Education figures this out and makes some changes.
Monday, February 14, 2011
Tuesday, January 18, 2011
VITRIOL, PUBLIC DISCOURSE, AND THE ROLE OF THE COLUMNIST
I think Dave Cramer said it best. At our churches’ annual meeting last Sunday, he repeatedly urged the congregation to “be firm in your beliefs, but be fair in your comments.” Dave is Emanuel Lutheran Church’s council president and he was speaking in regards to the highly contentious “gender issue” that is dividing the Evangelical Lutheran Churches of America, of which of Emanuel is, for now, a member.
However, this column is not about whether or not my congregation should leave the ELCA in response to some its position on gay pastors. Well—maybe it is a LITTLE about that—but, more generally, this column will deal with the general tone of debate in this country—the “vitriol” in our public discourse, so defined by Arizona Sheriff Dupnik.
Liberal talk radio host Chris Bradshaw (98.3 FM Des Moines) summarized the change in rhetoric as “We’ve gone from ‘I’m right; you’re wrong’ to ‘I’m right; you’re evil or you’re un-American or you’re un-Christian’.” I think both Bradshaw and Cramer have a point. Although there has always been strident political debate in America, the tone of this debate has definitely taken a sharp turn to the gutter in the past decade. AND—the standard to which we should ALL strive is that of disagreeing in a passionate way—but doing so in a civilized manner. In other words, if you don’t like my stand on the gender ruling or the war in Iraq—that’s fine—but you shouldn’t tell me I am unChristian or unAmerican because I disagree with you. And, yes, I have been called these things many times.
After quite a bit of research and pondering, I have decided that I do not think that the shooting of Congressperson Gabby Giffords was primarily inspired by political rhetoric. There is no evidence Jared Lee Loughner was a Palinite or a Glenn Beck fan or a Tea Partier. There is quite a bit of evidence that he was crazy as a loon. However, the horrific incident in an Arizona parking lot should serve as a wake-up call to all of us that actively participate in political debate.
And—by all of us I mean ME too. Do I—in my writings and my speeches—defend my beliefs passionately, while still remaining respectful of others? Not always. I have been known to throw the term “idiot” out when referring to Representative Steve King and to mock Sarah Palin at every given opportunity. Perhaps it is time for me to stop that—no matter how entertaining it is for you to read.
I, personally, have been particularly vitriolic in response to blog posters. They don’t have to sign their name so they can say truly nasty things with absolutely no accountability. This really ticks me off. SO—I “take the high road” and sign my name--but I say even nastier things back. Since I sign my name, does this make me a better person than “anonymous”?
I am beginning to think that that isn’t the point. It doesn’t seem to matter if I am “more right” than the person to whom I am responding—the power of my words is not changed by my “rightness” or my “wrongness.” Even the most innocuous speech can be taken to the extreme by an unhinged listener or reader and some of the comments I’ve made on blogs are certainly not innocuous. And—even if I am completely in the right—a deranged person can take my words, twist them, and use them as an excuse to do evil.
I’m pretty sure Sarah Palin didn’t mean anything malevolent when she placed cross hairs over Gifford’s district on her web site—it was just a oft-used symbol. BUT—every symbol has power and we all have to be careful of the symbols we throw around.
I will say that I have been careful to NEVER go as far as many of today’s talk radio icons. For example, I’ve never said anything CLOSE—in any forum--to this quote from Beck from May 17, 2005: ''I'm thinking about killing Michael Moore, and I'm wondering if I could kill him myself, or if I would need to hire somebody to do it. ... No, I think I could. I think he could be looking me in the eye, you know, and I could just be choking the life out. Is this wrong?''
Or this Beck quote from 2003:''Every night I get down on my knees and pray that Dennis Kucinich will burst into flames.''
I’ve also never said, “Have you ever noticed how all composite pictures of wanted criminals resemble Jesse Jackson?” Nopers—that racist quote belongs to Rush Limbaugh.
I could literally go on for pages citing conservative talk radio quotes that I DIDN’T say—but I think you get the point. Even though I have never said anything THAT bad (for one thing, I’m not THAT famous), I do need to learn a lesson from the Arizona tragedy and watch my vitriol as well—in all formats in which I publish.
So, I, for one, am going to try to do my small part to raise the standard of political discourse in regards to this column. I urge all my fellow commentators—liberal and conservative—to join me in this effort to be more civil. You hear that Glenn Beck, Rush Limbaugh, and Michael Savage—let’s work together to make a better world.
However, I’m thinking moderate speech doesn’t sell as well as vitriol and the Becks of the world will not temper their speech as long as they are making TONS of money. So, in order for the voice of reason to be heard, we all have to STOP buying the products that advertise on these offensive radio shows. Seriously—no more Snapple, no more pajamagrams, and not more Survival Seed Banks. If we want the voice of reason to be hard, we have to hit the “haters’ in the pocketbook and that means going after the advertisers. As long as Sean Hannity, Michael Savage, Glenn Beck, and Rush Limbaugh (among others) can make a gazillion dollars a day spewing hate—they are gonna keep doing it.
I, for one, do not get paid for my gig writing “Coffee Break,” so I guess you could say I have nothing to lose by “Oprahizing” my column. New Year’s Resolution #425: I will consider both sides when dealing with a controversial issue and I will not call people who disagree with me names. Resolution #426: I will actively boycott all products that advertise on shows that use vitriolic speech. Join me in these resolutions, my friends, and let’s work to make this word a better—safer—place.
Wednesday, January 5, 2011
No More Cloak and Dagger? OLD SCHOOL DIPLOMACY MEETS THE INFORMATION AGE
In early December, a web site entitled “Wikileaks” published 251,287 cables from more than 250 US embassies around the world, causing a great of embarrassment to the diplomatic community. Many of these cables do not paint our diplomats in a very good light. This includes Secretary of State, my girl, Hillary Rodham Clinton. Was this an example of good, old investigative journalism or espionage at its worst?
Apparently, it depends on who you ask—and, surprisingly, many tried and true liberals are agreeing with (gasp) Fox News on this one. Vice-President Joe Biden is one of those that insists that Wikileaks has “endangered lives and damaged U.S. diplomacy.” Others argue that Wikileaks is only doing its job as the “fourth branch of government” and using journalism to keep American politicians honest.
So—should a flaming liberal who also happens to dabble in journalism respect Wikileaks founder Julian Assange as a true journalist or call for his arrest because of the damage he caused to this Democratic administration? I’m afraid I have no clear answer to that question. Joe Biden—a good “lib” if I ever saw one--recently called Assange a “high tech terrorist” on “Meet the Press”—strangely echoing a statement from Sarah Palin. I guess politics do make for strange bedfellows.
The liberal website “The Progressive Reader” recently asked the question: “Is Julian Assange a courageous freedom fighter battling to buttress democracy through his dedication to government transparency, or a craven, shameless brat?” After conducting my research, I think perhaps the answer is both—Assange is a huge jerk who truly sees his website as doing a necessary and honorable service to the world.
There are some out there that says there has been no punishment at all for this huge leak of information. This simply isn’t true. The U.S.Army private that gave Assange the highly classified documents is currently paying some severe consequences. Bradley Manning has been in solitary confinement at the U.S. Marine brig in Quantico for five months now and the end is nowhere in site. His activities are severely restricted. He is not allowed to exercise and he has been denied a pillow and bed sheets. Before being sent to Quantico, he spent two months in a military jail in Kuwait. Manning could even be executed for his crime.
Assange’s punishment is a little bit trickier because his is an AUSTRALIAN citizen who lives in England. He can’t be a “traitor,” as some on Fox news have suggested, because he isn’t an American. The U.S. Justice Department is pulling no punches as it tries to punish Assange and get him in an American courtroom. They are currently seeking to have him extradited from England—and by the time you read this they very may well have succeeded. Most people seem to think they had a hand in his arrest in London on sex charges last month. The timing of arrest in a country with which the United States has a “special” relationship does seem more than a tad coincidental.
In addition to the problem of prosecuting someone in an American court who is not an American and who does not even live in America, many people around the world seem to idolize the pasty-faced computer hacker. Italy’s “Rolling Stone” magazine recently named him Rock Star of the Year. This makes the politics of extradition even trickier.
In conclusion, this liberal (for once) falls somewhere in the middle of this particular controversy. Obviously, it is appropriate to punish the private who initially gave the information to Wikileaks, although I would like him to be punished in a humane way. He stole documents from his workplace and that is a punishable offense. I am anti-death penalty in all cases, so I obviously don’t think a firing squad is in order.
As for Assange, I think the U.S. should stop pushing for his prosecution on what appears to be bogus rape charges and continue to look for legal ways to get him before an American judge and jury. And—the diplomatic corps needs to realize that in the 21st century there is no thing as “top secret” and they’d better be darn careful saying or writing anything they don’t want the world know.
Look for a column in upcoming weeks on one issue on which I DO have an opinion: the “don’t ask, don’t tell” rule in the military—and one issue on which I am still undecided: the new gun laws that went into effect in Iowa January 1. In the meantime, anyone with an opinion on either of these hot topics, drop me a line and give me some things to think about. Gotta do something to keep my mind from rotting during these cold Iowa winters!
Reflecting on the new Gun Law in iowa
If I had my druthers, all handguns would be illegal. Period. I’m a touchy, feely pacifist, dang it, and the thought of handguns scares me to death. And, apparently, handguns aren’t just for crazed psychopaths anymore. I was recently introduced to the new concept of pink handguns “for the ladies.” Just the thought made me throw up in my mouth a little. It is with this background that I am going to take a look at Iowa’s new gun law, which went into effect about two weeks ago.
YIKES! Although it makes sense to me that all 99 counties in Iowa should have the same rules on guns, some of the other provisions in the new law are downright frightening. The new law, for example, allows a person to carry a CONCEALED weapon into places that serve ALCOHOL. Seriously? Who thinks that is a good idea? I mean, who literally sat in a room and said, “Hey, let’s mix liquor and bullets—that’ll be a hit! It’s always worked so well in the inner cities.”?
Businesses, however, have the right to place a sign on their door that says they do no allow concealed weapons in their establishment. Yeah—I’m bettin’ that’s real enforceable. I ask the person who came up with this winner of an idea: if you can’t SEE the weapon because it is CONCEALED, how in the heck can you tell if a customer if violating your store’s rule? I mean, once they pull the gun on you, it’s a little late to deny service.
The new gun law also allows a person to carry their gun in plain sight. This means, a person can walk Fido at night while carrying a sidearm, in case they are attacked by squirrels or something. I don’t relish living in a society when people can just walk around with their gun in a holster like Little Joe in Bonanza. Remember how all of Little Joe’s girlfriends died before the end of the episode? Anyone else see a connection between that and his open carrying of a six shooter???? I’m thinking GUNS promote DEATH—just a thought.
Under the new law, authorities also cannot restrict the movement of people with loaded guns in vehicles. Another great combination---just like peanut butter and jelly, guns and automobiles are made for each other—NOT!
There are restrictions on gun ownership for convicted criminals and people under 21. Other than that—and the completion of a gun safety course--pretty much anything goes. The new unrestricted five-year gun permits are going like hotcakes, so apparently there are going to be a bunch of new gun owners carrying weapons on our fair streets and in our local businesses. Great—just great.
Hey, I have another idea. Let’s go ahead and make guns available to pretty much anyone for the asking and let them carry them openly, concealed, in their car, and even in their bicycle basket. However, let’s pass a new law that each bullet and/or shell must cost at least $10,000, with $9,950 of those dollars going to charity, education, and other good causes. Once again, I’ve taken life’s legislative lemons and turned them into lemonade. I’ve made the new gun law almost palatable and raised a ton of money for good causes. Now, if the solution to global warming were just that easy!
Monday, December 6, 2010
BRISTOL THE PISTOL IS A SYMBOL OF SOMETHING MUCH BIGGER
I’m addicted to reality talent shows and am fascinated with Sarah Palin. Hence, Sarah’s daughter Bristol’s stint on “Dancing with the Stars” held a particular interest for me. Two days after the final show of the season, I’m still not sure what to think of the “teen activist’s” third-place finish on one of my favorite TV shows.
First of all, she really wasn’t very good, although she was much, MUCH better than David Hasselhoff, Margaret Cho, and the Situation (who is an idiot, by the way). Secondly, she did improve a great deal as the season progressed. Thirdly, I almost felt sorry for her at the end. Other than having a famous, polarizing mom and an jerk ex-boyfriend, she really has done nothing to deserve the abuse she ended up taking, other than quit her job as a receptionist for a much higher-profile gig as a contestant on America’s number one-rated show.
A quick Google search shows that a lot of Americans cares very deeply about how well Alaska’s first daughter fared on DWTS. Reactions to her success were often extreme: a man ended up in jail after a police standoff which resulted from him shooting his television when Bristol beat Brandy to make the finals; Bristol received death threats on the set and even a envelope full of a “white, powdery substance” that looked a lot like anthrax. Wow! Those are some extreme reactions to a celebrity dance contest!
So—why all this extreme reaction to such a seemingly innocuous television show? The answer lies, of course, with the polarizing personality of the Mama Grizzly herself: Sarah Palin. ABC had no problem whatsoever showcasing Bristol’s mom every chance they had. As a matter of fact, I’m pretty sure Sarah did more actual talking on the show than Bristol, who appears quite shy.
Sarah’s amazing popularity and the activism of Tea Partiers were certainly the largest reasons behind Bristol’s success. She had basically no fan base going into the show and she is a very timid dancer. The fans voted for her week after week because they like her mother—and perhaps because they wanted to send yet another message to America: we’re conservatives, we’re proud, and we have POWER—get used to it!
I just can’t help, but thinking that Bristol is a pawn in her mother’s ever-present quest for media attention. As if “Sarah Palin’s Alaska” and her new book aren’t enough reason for her to be in the spotlight—she also sat right there in the front row most every week, rooting for her daughter—and looking quite fetching as she did so.
Even little sister Willow jumped into the spotlight last week with her homophobic, profane rant on Facebook, where she used words like Faggot and the f-bomb with astounding ease. Bristol joined in with some harsh language herself. So much for America’s sweetheart, I guess. Actually, I can’t say I blame Bristol or her sixteen-year-old sister for lashing back—things were getting pretty nasty and sometimes a girl’s gotta take a stand. I’m not sure Facebook is the proper venue, but sisters stick together—even conservative, Alaskan sisters—and that’s a good thing.
Once again, I find myself having a lot in common with the Palin clan. Occasional potty mouth: check. Habit of airing my dirty laundry on Facebook: check. Dedication to say or do whatever necessary to protect my family: check. Need for the spotlight: check. Not having a problem using my families’ accomplishments to get a little of that spotlight myself: check (and have you met my amazing football-playing daughter Josie?).
Too bad Sarah’s not a “Lib,” as my conservative friends call me. If that were true, maybe I would have even voted for Bristol myself—even though she couldn’t dance very well. Or maybe not. Would I vote for someone that lacked talent just because I like them? Let’s find out: someone out there there has to be a Democratic son or daughter that wants to compete on “Dancing with the Stars” and we’ll test my theory. Wouldn’t it be fun to watch Chelsea Clinton shake her groove thing against, say, the Rock and Phyllis Diller—with Bill and Hillary sitting in the front row each night? I’m tellin’ ya, ABC—that lineup would be a ratings success! Call me, let’s talk.
It’s a ZOMBIE Christmas!
Patrick, of late, has become obsessed with zombies. Anything having to do with the undead holds a great fascination for my youngest child. Apparently he is not the only person affected by this obsession. A quick Google search finds 24,000,000 hits for “zombies.”
Zombies where first made famous by George Romer's “Night of the Living Dead” back in 1965. I remember one Halloween when I was at Coe. I was waiting for a friend to pick me up for a party and decided to fritter away the time watching this film. BAD IDEA. I had to have aforementioned friend sleep on my couch for a week after, as I was too petrified of the living dead to sleep alone.
A more recent addition to zombie literature is the new AMC series “The Walking Dead.” According to the official website, this series is based on the comic book by Robert Kirkman and tells the story of life following a zombie apocalypse. Patrick has turned the watching of this show into his weekly “date night” with Mom. Every Sunday at nine will find he and I snuggled on the couch, drinking cocoa and watching zombies try to catch humans and eat them. We have a surprisingly good time at this; even I’ve begun to care for the fate of county sheriff Rick Grimes and his family in the wake of the unspeakable.
I went to the “Walking Dead” web site and took a quiz to see what type of survivor I would be in case of a zombie attack. According to this site, I’d be one “tough chick,” defending my kiddos at all cost from the scourge of the undead. Cool.
I went to the “Walking Dead” web site and took a quiz to see what type of survivor I would be in case of a zombie attack. According to this site, I’d be one “tough chick,” defending my kiddos at all cost from the scourge of the undead. Cool.
Patrick and Cody are both reading a book entitled “A Zombie Survival Guide” and I bought a hilarious parody of Jane Austen entitled “Pride and Prejudice and Zombies.” I tell ya, this zombie thing is taking over my entire house.
Cody has a pretty detailed theory regarding zombie symbolism that he has actually talked his English teacher into writing into this year’s choral reading. There is a zombie fan page on Facebook. Daniel Drezner has written a treatise called “Theory of International Politics and Zombies.” Zombies, zombies—they’re everywhere!
We recently watched “Dawn of the Dead” while driving home from the Breitsprecher Christmas in Independence. Well—Dean was driving; the rest of us were in the back watching. Then we had a spirited family discussion regarding the safest place to hide during a zombie attack. We finally agreed on a maximum-security prison as the ideal hideaway: very secure, lots of weapons available, and weightlifting equipment for entertainment and exercise made it the perfect place. I kept trying to talk the kids into hiding in a shoe store—but they didn’t think that would be very practical. It was really fun riding home from Indee, looking at the Christmas lights and discussing zombies as a family.
When I was younger and dreamed of the perfect Christmas with my children, I never imagined spending it watching the undead overtake Atlanta. I imagined something more idyllic and less bloody. But, you know, cuddled up under my leopard snuggie with Patrick is even better than the enjoying the Christmas lights in a one-horse open sleigh fantasy of my childhood.
I guess we can add “enjoying horror movies” to the list of things I said I’d NEVER before I had children. I hope each and every one of you is able to add a new Christmas tradition to your wheelhouse of traditions this holiday season like I was able to add to mine. It may not be baking sugar cookies from scratch, but discussing the perfect place to hide when zombies rule the earth is a fine way to spend Christmas Day
Our Iowa article
ALGONA ARTIST PLAYS MICHELANGELO AT CENTURY FARM
St. Peter’s Basilica in Rome has nothing on a century farm located only a few miles outside of Algona. As a matter of fact, Michelangelo himself might be impressed with the work of local artist and high school teacher Mark Haverkamp, who has been painting murals of rural scenes on the home of Mike and Roseanne Schmit for the past several years. Yes—you read correctly: ON the home.
Mike and Roseanne came across this unique artistic idea on one of their many trips to Europe. Both the Schmits have roots deep in Luxembourg and Germany and have visited that area quite a few times since the early 1970’s. On a visit to Oberammergau, Germany they saw many examples of this unique kind of art: scenes literally painted on the sides of home. Upon returning home, they commissioned local artist Dave Strickland to paint a scene on their double garage.
Since then, they have commissioned Haverkamp to paint five scenes on their house proper, with two more in the works. According to the artist, “The couple likes scenes with the theme of Early American Farming. I have been painting these scenes in a more-or-less progressive manner. I started with scenes from the pioneer days and then added some from the 1920’s. The last scene I painted for the Schmits was from the 1950’s era.
“Mike provides photos and other ideas that conjure up memories of his childhood. Some of these ideas have come from covers of magazines like Wallace’s Farmers and others have come from books. I combine the ideas and work up a rough sketch. We work from there,” she said.
Mary started out painting the murals directly onto the house itself, but had trouble getting the paint to adhere. “It didn’t stick too well because of the oil-based stain on the house,” she said. “Even though we tried to remove the stain, enough remained to cause a problem.”
Another problem she encountered was how, exactly, to get up high enough to use her paintbrushes. “I started with a stepladder and then Mike set me up some scaffolding. The scaffolding was more secure, but I was still out in the weather, dealing with the bugs and the heat and the wind. Finally we solved both problems by painting the scenes on thin sheets of plywood and then adhering them to the house after they were completed. This has worked much better,” said Mary.
It isn’t just the large murals of one-room schoolhouses and horse-drawn plows that make the Schmit farm unique. The original homestead of the property, built in approximately 1857, has been restored and sits basically in the front yard of the main house. The log cabin was built by Mike and Sarah Schmit, who emigrated to the New World from Luxembourg when land became scarce there. “They basically had two choices: move to France and work in the coal mines or come to the ‘New Country’. They chose to emigrate in 1855,” said Mike.
Mike and Sarah lived in the one-room cabin until 1886 and raised three children there. “I imagine it was pretty crowded,” said Rose, “with three young children underfoot in that tiny cabin. I think they probably spent a lot of time outside.”
When Mike started farming the land at the tender age of 16, he had no idea the log cabin was even there. The structure had been covered with siding and used in a variety of capacities. After purchasing the property from his father’s estate when he was 21, Mike discovered the cabin and uncovered its fascinating history.
Today the 19’ x 20’ cabin, which was built with locally grown oak, is restored and decorated with old quilts and other antiques from a day gone by. “I’m even using one of our wedding presents out there—at slightly over fifty years it isn’t exactly an antique, but it still has plenty of memories,” said Rose.
Mike, the grandson of the original owner, and Rose have one daughter Denise and three grandchildren. Denise used to have sleepovers with her girlfriends in the old cabin. “One time they were scared in a thunderstorm, so I had to bring a cot out and sleep downstairs while they camped in the lot,” said Mike.
“When I moved into the old farmhouse as a newlywed, my sister-in-law told me to be patient, I’d ‘get a new house eventually.’ Little did I know that not only would I build a beautiful house in 1977, but I’d also play a part in uncovering and restoring an historic log cabin. I guess you could say I have two houses now.”
Between the cabin and the beautiful, original murals of rural farm life from days gone by, the Schmit century.farm is a unique piece of property indeed.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)